Cellular Vs. Satellite
Three years ago, I left the big city (Alexandria, VA) to move to the tiny mountain valley town of Luray, Virginia. It was a return to my roots as a small-town boy…a bit of a culture shock after decades in the city…and a place literally bereft of broadband.
There was DSL available…only not where I live. Cable stops about 300 feet from my house, and Comcast killed the project before it reached me. So I weighed the options of optical wireless or satellite, and elected to go with Hughes.net. Understand, I appreciate the fact that Hughes Satellite even provides service to rural customers. But between the service outages, the constant modem reboots, and the ridiculous service caps, I was not happy. I once spent 24 hours with sub-dialup speeds for violating the Hughes Terms of Service download limits — I downloaded a Microsoft trial software program.
So I was pleasantly surprised when both Verizon and Sprint began offering the Novatel MiFi product at a reasonable price. The MiFi is basically a cellular broadband reciever combined with a wifi router. About the size of four credit cards stacked together and with an impressive battery life, this little device is the NEXT BIG THING in rural broadband — and for accounting firms fielding audit and IT teams.
It connects easily, has WPA-secure wifi connections, and while it is only 802.11g and b-compatible today, an 802.11n version is in the works. It downloads at 800K to about 1 Mb — roughtly twice the speed of satellite connections. Uploads are a little slower, but only a little. The wifi router can handle up to five simultaneous connections.
Translated, this means that an accounting firm can field a team to a client location, set up its own secure network on the site, and work there for as long as it needs to. The device is portable, and the service plan is about $40 per month. No need to use the client’s network or public wifi sites. Up to five simultaneous connections and you are good to go.
So what does all this mean? For rural customers who can get DSL or cable, not much. You already have one of the best, low-cost Internet connections. But for those of us who choose to live on the side of a mountain or the middle of the wheat fields, this is a critical technology. It means we can use a cell tower, if one is nearby, to get decent broadband. The 5Gb download limit is not overly generous, but I haven’t busted the limit in two months of average small-office use, either.
And what it really means is that today, in the Shenandoah River valley of Virginia, I have another credible broadband choice. And it means that I will be disconnecting my satellite connection next month to make the move to cellular broadand.
And if it is good now, I can’t wait for the deployment of LTE starting in 2010.
Dave - a very timely post. I’m about to head to a rural part of Washington State to help a friend recover from knee surgery, and the only service she can get is Satellite. I’m crossing my fingers it works!
I wish I could share a great story like that also…. My in-laws recently relocated to Pollocksville, NC population 256. It doesn’t get much more rural. And sadly with such a small population 3G connectivity from any provider is dismal. I had to drive 20 minutes to Jacksonville, NC to work for the day
That being said, the MiFi is great, I used to use the Kyocera KR-1 routers with the aircard int he same manner. But having it all in one little package is sweet!